This is not a diet debate. In this episode of Health Coach Radio, Erin Power sits down with Mollie Engelhart, a former vegan icon and celebrated Los Angeles restaurateur whose identity and livelihood were built on plant-based ideology.
Today, Mollie is a regenerative rancher. That transition cost her millions of dollars, professional relationships, and public approval — and she would still do it again. This conversation explores what happens when evidence and lived experience challenge deeply held beliefs, especially when those beliefs are tied to morality, identity, and income.
To learn how to become a health coach or to up-level your skills and credentials as a health coach, visit primalhealthcoach.com.
Former vegan icon Mollie Engelhart is a now a regenerative rancher.
Episode Overview:
- 0:00 From vegan restaurateur to Texas cattle rancher
- 1:16 Changing your mind when your identity depends on it
- 2:13 Why all food systems involve death
- 7:07 Discovering regenerative agriculture and soil health
- 14:21 Why veganism once made sense
- 20:03 The duck story and the shift to stewardship
- 27:10 Vegan mindset vs rancher mindset
- 34:19 Soil as the foundation of health
- 45:31 Hydroponics and the illusion of nutrition
- 50:21 The Small Farm Diet
- 52:02 Feeding communities, not the planet
- 59:13 Final message on responsibility and belonging
What This Conversation Covers
Changing your mind publicly
Mollie shares the hardest version of change: shifting beliefs when you are financially dependent on being right. Her move away from veganism began with curiosity about soil health and regenerative agriculture and led to a deeper understanding of food systems and responsibility.
The myth of “harmless” food
Plant-based food is often framed as bloodless or impact-free. Mollie explains why all agriculture involves death and disruption, whether through fertilizers, tilling, harvesting, or monocropping. The difference is whether that impact supports regeneration or industrial extraction.
Vegan ethics vs. ecological reality
Mollie honors the ethical motivations behind veganism while explaining why simplified moral frameworks break down when viewed at the ecosystem level, particularly when influenced by industrial interests.
From rescue to stewardship
Humans are meant to be active stewards (Keystone species), not isolated observers, of nature. We must stop treating the symptoms of a broken system and re-engage with the natural order.
Why soil changes everything
Mollie’s central message is clear: the soil is not depleted, it is biologically dead. She explains why microbes are essential for nutrient availability, how modern food contributes to metabolic dysfunction, and why human health is inseparable from soil health.
The small farm diet
Rather than rigid food labels, Mollie advocates for a small farm diet: local, seasonal, human-scaled, and intentionally inconvenient. Convenience, she argues, has quietly replaced resilience.
Connect with Mollie at:
- Book: Debunked by Nature (foreword by Joel Salatin)
- Website: debunkedbynature.com
- Instagram: @talktomollie
- Ranch & Products: sovereigntyranch.com
- Restaurant: The Barn Restaurant (@eatatthebarn)
Listen via the player below, or subscribe in iTunes or your preferred podcast streaming service.
Ready to turn your passion for health into lasting impact?
Health Coach Radio is your backstage pass into the world of health and fitness coaching, hosted by Primal Health Coach Institute Coaching Director, Erin Power and powered by the legacy of founder Mark Sisson. Each episode is packed with real stories, expert strategies, and practical inspiration to help you grow as a coach and make a difference.
Curious about what’s possible for your own health coaching journey?
Visit primalhealthcoach.com to learn how Primal Health Coach Institute can help you transform lives—including your own—through the power of coaching and ancestral health.
